The conversation went like this:
Son: I like that garden over there. That’s what I want to do when I grow up.
Father: Why?
Son: Because you get to grow things, eat things, and play in the dirt. Plus, you are outside all day long with constant water breaks.
Father: Wouldn’t you get lonely outside all day with just the plants?
Son: No. I can listen to music and pet the friendly dogs that walk by. Most conversation is not much fun. Besides, if I want conversation, the neighbors always want to talk.
Father: What do you think Mom will say?
Son: I’ll explain to her that she won’t have to buy lettuce or tomatoes unless, of course, she wants to buy them from me.
Father: What will she say about school?
Son: Gardening isn’t a full-time job, and with bad weather, I will have to come indoors and live like my friends. Like so many kids I know, I can learn things on my computer.
Father: That doesn’t sound like much education to me.
Son: Which are we talking about, Dad? Learning from home on my computer or learning outdoors? I think you are right that my friends won’t be getting much education. They won’t find learning fun. That will not be true about me. I will learn so much, and about things that I care to learn about.
Father: Well, if you are going to become a gardener, can we at least consider what type? What will your approach be? Will you have a strategy?
Son: “Strategy” sounds like a big word for growing some plants. What do you mean?
Father: Take a look at the garden across the street.
Son: I see it. So what?
Father: What are some differences you note?
Son: One has energy and beauty in a wild kind of way. This one looks organized, has a structure, and is a lot taller.
Father: Aren’t you curious why the structure exists? What was that gardener thinking?
Son: Yes, kind of. That might be an example of a learning opportunity by doing it my way. Would I have to choose one of these two options?
Father: I just think that whether you become a gardener, or a scientist, or a teacher, or a musician, or whatever, you should always have a strategy.
Son: It doesn’t feel like we are talking about becoming a gardener anymore. Now it sounds like you are talking about my future, and success, and things that a twelve-year-old doesn’t want to think about.
Father: I was just thinking that this might help you become a better gardener and, on a practical level, get the order from Mom that you can do as you wish.
Son: Ok, but do I need to be prepared to answer questions like, “Will the garden be organic? Or is it just for us? Or how much will it cost to set up?”
Father: Well, if you answer those questions, you will show yourself to be very prepared. I think we’ve learned that you can never be too prepared.
Son: Just like we’ve learned, there are different ways to become educated. I think I’ve decided to go for the combo garden — wild and organized at the same time. To use a word that you will like, it will be a “hybrid.”
Silence…
Son: Gotta go, Dad… now I am busy executing what you call “The strategy.”
Author’s note: I am getting ready to work on a series of “musings” for our children that will eventually make their way into a book, “Keep Your Chin Up and Your Heart Open.” This might be a piece I include—the nature of how we learn, the strength to go alternative ways, and the way we explore these topics with the adults in our lives.
This conversation is such a tender reminder of how kids teach us as much as we teach them. I love the way the son’s curiosity and clarity shine through, wise beyond his years, with dirt under his nails and a plan in his heart. That hybrid garden sounds like the start of something beautiful.
I found myself immediately wanting to know who the father and son were. The son did not sound like Alfred. Joey? Maybe. Anyway, that's because I'm steeped in your Alfred series. Guess I want to "type-cast" you. Sorry. . . You are off to a good start. Kids do need alternative education/career paths these days—some more than others. Your book could help them and their parents think about and learn how to discuss options.